bestdish

How BestDish ranks dishes

BestDish ranks individual dishes in Manchester, not restaurants. A dish's position comes from three kinds of evidence, all of which you can see on its page, added up as a score.

The score

Every ranked dish has a score, shown beside it as points. The score is three things added together: votes, points from published sources, and the restaurant's own pick. Each dish page prints the sum line by line.

A vote is 1 point
A vote says you have had the dish and rate it. Anyone can vote, without an account, once per dish. You can take a vote back.
A published source is 1 to 7 points

When a critic, guide or local publication writes about a dish, we record it with a word-for-word quote and a link to the original. A source is a publication, not an individual critic. It earns points for who published it, plus points for how strongly the quote praises the dish.

Who published it

  • A national critic or guide (The Guardian, The Good Food Guide, Michelin Guide, SquareMeal, The Infatuation): 5 points
  • A Manchester publication (Manchester Confidential, Manchester's Finest, Manchester Evening News, The Manc, I Love Manchester, Secret Manchester): 3 points
  • Reddit: 1 point
  • Any other publisher: 2 points

How strongly it praises the dish

  • The dish is mentioned favourably or simply described. Nothing extra.
  • The dish is clearly recommended. 1 point extra.
  • The dish is singled out as a highlight, a must-order or the best of its kind. 2 points extra.

The praise level is judged by software, from the quoted words alone. If you think one is wrong, tell us and we will look at it.

Each publisher counts once per dish; if it has written about the dish more than once, its strongest source counts. Sources more than 4 years old, and sources with no known date, are still shown on the dish page but earn nothing.

A restaurant's own pick is 5 points
A restaurant can tell us which dish it would send people to. That dish is marked as chosen by the restaurant.

The score is the sum. Sources and a restaurant's pick give a new dish a fair starting position; as votes build up, they decide the order. Ties go to the dish with more votes.

How a dish gets listed

Dishes come from restaurant menus, from published sources, from restaurants themselves and from visitors who add one. A dish is ranked once it has a recent published source, a restaurant's nomination, or five votes. Suggestions are checked before they appear.

What we do not do

Where restaurant details come from

Restaurant names and addresses come partly from the Food Standards Agency's food hygiene register. Contains Food Standards Agency data © Crown copyright and database right, licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. We do not show hygiene ratings.

Corrections

If a dish has left a menu or a detail is wrong, tell us. If you run a restaurant, add your dishes and photos.